|
By Claus Bonnez, Chairman of the
KRIM-organisation in Denmark
The Council of Europe's
Committee for the Prevention of Torture (“the CPT”) has announced
that the committee will visit Denmark and 9 other member-states in
2008.
The CPT has a right to visit
institutions, where persons deprived of their liberty by the
authorities are held, in all states which are members of the Council
of Europe.
The CPT has asked the Danish NGO “KRIM” to meet the CPT at Hotel
Neptun in Copenhagen on February 11th 2008 at 3 pm. KRIM
is invited to put forward KRIM’s views on the state of affairs in
Denmark.
In 1996 KRIM also had the opportunity to meet the CPT on their visit
to Denmark. At the meeting in 1996 KRIM told the CPT, that KRIM
offered advice and legal assistance to prisoners in prisons and
remand houses across Denmark, and that KRIM generally believed that
prisoners were treated in a way, which never or very rarely
infringed on the rights of the prisoners guaranteed by the European
Convention on Human Rights.
In the period between 1996 and 2008 KRIM has gradually reached the
conclusion, that prisoners in Danish institutions in several ways
are treated in ways which infringe on their human rights. It’s sad
to admit that the situation after 2002 in particular has
deteriorated.
KRIM is aware of the fact, that the CPT visited Denmark in 2002, and
that the CPT has issued a report to the government of Denmark on the
visit. In the report Denmark was recommended to introduce a number
of changes regarding the way persons deprived of their liberty are
treated in Denmark.
KRIM has decided first and foremost to comment on some of the issues
which, according to the report, caused the CPT concern on their
visit in 2002. Eventually KRIM will point out other issues, which in
KRIMs opinion might be of interest to the CPT.
Legal costs in criminal cases
In § 19 the CPT recommends “that police officers be firmly reminded
that they should not seek to dissuade detained persons from
exercising their right of access to a lawyer. Further, the
requirement that the police inform detained persons of their
potential liability as regards costs should extend to the fact that
the court may decide to limit that liability”.
KRIM is often consulted by persons who claim that as they cannot
afford the cost of a lawyer they decide against asking for one. In
Denmark it is a well-known fact, that many people who have served a
prison sentence are burdened with a big debt, which is due to legal
costs. In Denmark there is no access to legal aid in criminal cases.
Persons charged with an offence are obliged to repay to the state
the costs of having had access to a lawyer during their case. In
minor cases it’s not compulsory to be represented in court by a
lawyer. A great number of persons appear in court without a lawyer.
The Danish enforcement-authority has decided that persons who owe
money to the state have no access to have the debt remitted. There
is no statute barrier. This means that a great number of persons are
unable to pay their debt possibly for the rest of their lives. Many
previously convicted persons tell KRIM, that the reason why they
stay away from the job-market after their release from prison is the
high debt to the Danish State. They know that as long as they stay
on social security they are not asked to repay the money. Only if
they venture into a job, will they be contacted by the authorities
in order to pay instalments on their debts.
It’s common that social
security-recipients owe insurmountable sums to the state. Often a
person is asked to reimburse DKK 200.000 – 300.000 after release
from prison. They often tell KRIM that for that reason – they decide
not to undertake a job. The KRIM-staff often gets the impression
that they accept to live on income support and perhaps the revenues
from for instance petty crimes KRIM believes that the Danish system
might infringe with article 6 of the European Convention on Human
Rights. See Croysant v. Germany.
KRIM has the impression that no other country in the world leaves
released prisoners to a life with big debts due to legal costs they
are unable to repay to the state. It appears that convicted persons
in some other countries are also required to pay the costs of their
lawyer, but it also appears that in these countries the convicted
persons has a chance to have the debts cancelled if they are able to
prove that they are unable to pay.
On www.krim.dk there are a number
of articles on legal costs in criminal cases (mostly in Danish):
I andre lande forgældes domfældte ikke af
sagsomkostninger
Sagsomkostninger fører til, at uskyldige
bliver straffet
EMK om sagsomkostninger i Danmark
Remand prisoners access to see a doctor of their own choice
In § 20 “the CPT considers that detained persons should have the
right to be examined by a doctor of their own choice in all cases;
if it were thought that such a contact could obstruct the
investigation, the examination could always take place in the
presence of a state-appointed doctor”.
KRIM is in touch with a great number of persons who have been in
custody. No prisoners are aware of the fact that they are allowed to
be examined by a doctor of their own choice. It is the opinion of
KRIM’s opinion that a prisoner is never allowed access to a doctor
of their own choice.
Negatively strong
prisoners
KRIM has noted that the CPT in § 33 recommends that a decision to
classify a prisoner as negatively strong be reviewed at regular
intervals (e.g. every three months). Further, it would like to be
informed of the exact criteria for classifying a prisoner as
negatively strong.
KRIM believes that the access of the prison authorities to classify
prisoners as “negatively strong” to a very large degree is being
used to circumvent the European Prison Rules. The European Prison
Rules issue prisoners with the right to be informed about the
charges if they are charged with a disciplinary offence in the
prison. In the summer 2002 a new law was passed. The new law gives
the prison authorities the right not to inform a prisoner about the
reasons, if the authorities decide to move the prisoner to another
prison for instance from an open institution to a closed institution
or if it is decided to isolate the prisoner from other prisoners.
The prisoner has no longer the right to see any files in his own
case on which the decision is based. Therefore the prisoner has no
reasonable chance to prepare his or her defence.
Often prisoners who are spokesmen for other prisoners or prisoners
who publicize critical opinions in the media on the prison service
report to KRIM that they with out notice and without any reason are
told that they now are classified as negatively strong prisoners and
for that reason are transferred to closed prisons or to isolation
cells.
Many prisoners consult KRIM with allegations that they have been
exposed to gross infringements in their rights. Often they refuse to
accept interference from KRIM because their fear that the staff
might decide to classify them as negatively strong prisoners.
Initially negatively strong prisoners were offered the same
possibilities as other prisoners. Some prisoners actually reported
to KRIM, that negatively strong prisoners were offered better
conditions than those of other prisoners.
The conditions for negatively strong prisoners have been tightened
to a large degree since the summer 2002. A very old and dark prison
was closed in 1992 after allegations on violence against prisoners.
In 2004 after a minor refurbishment the prison was reopened. The
prison is an old remand centre at the Copenhagen Police
Headquarters. The Danish Home Secretary (justitsministeren)
announced that the prison was reopened in order to accommodate
negatively strong prisoners. The stay in the prison was meant to be
an additional punishment. A tough regime based on isolation was
introduces. The prisoners are lucked up in their cells apart from
one hour a day. They are isolated, and they are only allowed to
associate with one other prisoner picked by the prison staff. Only
two prisoners are allowed out of their cells at a time. A
press-release from the Home Secretary gives the impression that the
purpose of the new prison is to give the prisoners kept there a hard
time. Prisoners can stay in the prison for an indefinite period of
time.
KRIM is aware of the fact that a number of very vulnerable prisoners
who burden the prison staff in other prisons are being classified as
negatively strong prisoners. Some of them have been sent to the
above mentioned prison;
The KRIM-staff has been asked if they are aware of examples of
prisoners who have been classified as negatively strong who have
managed to have that classification altered. Most staff believes
that it hasn’t happened at all.
Prisoners work and
education
In § 48 the CPT mentions the lack of access to work “preferably with
vocational value” in prisons. Over the past years KRIM has received
many complaints from prisoners who want to embark on an education
while in prison. Their request is often turned down for economical
reasons. A long term prisoners at the Herstedvester Prison (doing
security detention) wanted to do an a-level course. The school found
that he had the qualifications. His application was turned down
because the prison was unable to pay his tuition fee which amounts
to approximately DKK 3.000 a year. The course is needed to get
access to the university. The prisoner wants to study law. He
expects to spend many years in prison, and he believes that he could
get far on a law course if the prison service would allow him to do
so. Another prisoner in the same prison feels that the prison
sabotaged his Dutch-course at the Copenhagen University.
Individual custody plans
KRIM is aware of the fact that many long term prisoners have no
individual custody plan even though they ask for one (§ 49).
Confidentiality of medical data
In the Herstedvester Prison
which accommodate prisoners with psychiatric disorders many
prisoners complain about the fact that the non-medical staff (the
prison warders) have full access to their files. Some of the
prisoners tell that they are ridiculed by the prison warders who
have got access to information from their files. It is a policy in
the Danish prison service that the “uniformed staff” has influence
on all matters concerning the prisoners life in prisons. They
participate in the decision making about each prisoner. They have an
influence for instance about whether a prisoner should be released
on parole or not. The prisoners often mention to KRIM that they feel
very unsafe about that. They feel that many prison warders weight
irrelevant criteria while making their decisions on the prisoners. A
prisoner at Herstedvester tells that he was met by scornful
nicknames such as El Gordo (the fat person) after it was mentioned
in his medical record that he wanted to loose weight. In a report
about treatment of sex offenders the prison tells about the fact,
that prison warders participate in the decision making on individual
prisoners also their medical treatment. The report has the
title: "Behandling af sædelighedskriminelle i Anstalten ved
Herstedvester" and is written by the psychiatrist Steen Mollerup in
2006.
Avenues of complain about
ill-treatment in prisons
In § 63 the CPT highlight the need for prisoners ”avenues of
complaint about ill-treatment in prisons. KRIM is aware of the fact
that the European Court on Human Rights over the years has developed
a standard which means that the authorities have to make thorough
examinations into allegations from prisoners that they have been
victims of a treatment incompatible with article 2 in European
Convention on Human Rights. KRIM believes that the prison
authorities make very little effort to examine what has happened
when prisoners complain about ill-treatment. The authorities accept
the statements made by the staff. The prison service publishes no
statistics about the number of complaints received and hence forward
there is no statistics available about the number of persons whose
complaints are accepted.
Prisoners who complain about
the prison service have no access to have the fee for their lawyer
paid for by public funds.
The Home office has recently
ruled that the prison service was allowed to overhear a telephone
conversation between a prisoner and his lawyer. It was not argued
from the prison that the prison suspected the lawyer (or the
prisoner) of any crime or dubious behaviour. The home office
accepted that the conversation was overheard even though the prison
did not give any actual reason.
The decision is obviously infringing the principles in Campbell v.
United Kingdom.
Absenteeism among
custodial staff and the problem of prison staff who do not “venture
outside” their offices in the units
In § 65 the CPT highlights the problems of a relatively high level
of absenteeism among custodial staff. In § 66 the CPT discusses the
staff who do not “venture outside their offices located within the
units”.
Prisoners very often report
to KRIM that a group of prison staff is not bothered with the
prisoners at all. Their complaints have not led to any change. In
the Easter 2007 a large national daily newspaper (Jyllands Posten)
disclosed statements from prison staff who told the newspaper that
they had dropped out from the prison service because a group of
“negatively strong prison staff” intimidated other staff from doing
their job properly. Staff who wanted to assist the prisoners in
getting on in their lives where discouraged to do so. They were told
that assistance to prisoners meant more work. Over the autumn about
60 articles were printed on the subject. Initially all interviews
were anonymous eventually they were named. A prison governor left
her job in September 2007. She claimed that she was bullied by
negatively strong prison warders at Herstedvester. A women prison
officer at the new prison in East Jylland claimed that she was told
by other prison warders, that she would be screwed in her arse if
she told tales about unacceptable behaviour from other members of
the staff. A new Home Office Report from 2005 suggests that the
prison service face serious problems because a number of prison
warders do not accept the rules of the prison and make their own
rules. The report suggests that they are not bothered to work but
spend their working hours watching television and playing cards with
other staff.
Prisoners have often
complained about brutal staff to KRIM over the past years. In remand
houses there is – according to many prisoners – an unwritten rule
saying that prisoners are not supposed to ring the bell after
closing-up hours at 9.30 pm. The prisoners are expected to urine in
the hand basin.
Prison staff has also
reported to the press during 2007, that prisoners who bother the
staff with many request may end up in the fixation cell. They claim
that prisoners are beaten up.
The Director of the Prison
Head Quarters has responded to the many cases in the news papers
that he is unable to prove anything.
The Home Office has refused
to open an independent examination. They have asked a solicitor to
look at the problem. The solicitor normally represents the
government in cases where the government is sued by citizens. It is
not believed by KRIM that the solicitor dare put forward criticism.
In early February newspapers revealed that prison staff at
Herstedvester intimidates witnesses who are called to give
statements to the solicitor.
KRIM believes that the problem with negatively strong prison staff
has escalated over the past 6-7 years. The prison staff has made
campaigns in the press where they have gained sympathy from a group
of MPs by telling that negatively strong prisoners rule the prisons
due to the tolerant and lenient regimes in Danish prisons. Other
groups of staff (teachers and social workers) have had very little
say. A prison governor claims that the ratio of other groups of
staff in Danish prisons is relatively low compared to other
countries. KRIM doesn’t know whether that is true or not.
Prisoners often tell to KRIM
that they find it difficult to get through to other staff than
prison warders in the prisons. They are simply not there according
to some prisoners.
KRIM has published a number
of articles on so called negatively strong prison staff (all in
danish):
Ledere i kriminalforsorgen ønsker indsats mod
negativ betjent-kultur i hele kriminalforsorgen - 2007
Fængselsbetjente presser andre faggrupper ud
af kriminalforsorgen - 2007
Begrebet "stærke og negative indsatte" bruges
i fængselsforbundets fagpolitiske kamp
Fængselsbetjente frygter at komme i "bad
standing" hos tyranniske kolleger - november 2007
Nyansatte fængselsbetjente- Mobning af de
indsatte er en "udbredt kultur" i danske fængsler - november 2007
Indsatte føler sig mere udsat for vold og
trusler fra personalet end fra medindsatte - 2001
Topics not on the agenda
in 2002
Security Detention
Prisoners in security detention are offered no contradictory
examination when the psychiatrists at Herstedvester have decided
that they are not yet ready for release.
Handcuffs and belt
A new trend has developed in the Danish prison service. An
increasing number of prisoners are being put in handcuffs or belts
during transport. This also applies to prisoners who have no record
of violence to the staff. Prisoners are also asked to appear in
court handcuffed.
Convicted prisoners in isolation
Many prisoners in Danish prisons are being held in isolation for a
number of years. Their situation is not regularly reviewed, and
because of the new law mentioned in the paragraph on negatively
strong prisoners above, they are not given any reason. They feel
that they don’t know what to do in order to obtain access to the
company of their fellow inmates again.
KRM has had fairly good contact with a convicted prisoner who has
been kept in isolation for about 4 years. He has been exposed to
"homemade" rules made individually to him. He has had strict
limitations for instance to the number of underpants he is allowed
to possess (maximum 7 pairs). He is regularly moved around between
prisons and between cells. No other prisoners are allowed to be on
the landing, if he is out of his cell. The prisoner is for long
periods not allowed to use the exercise room in the wing for
isolated prisoners. The prisoner is supposed to undergo regular
strip searches even though he is kept away from other prisoners. The
prisoner regularly shows signs of being psychotic. It's KRIMs
impression that the prisoners mental state deteriorates at a brisk
pace due to the conditions he is exposed to.KRIM has described that
particular prisoners situation on the following link:
Kan man drive isolationsfangen Jan Henrik
vanvittig- - følg med her! It
is also KRIMs impression that he is a very vulnerable prisoner.
An other vulnerable prisoner
has also been kept isolated for a number of years. He is now kept in
isolation in the prison designed for negatively strong prisoners in
Copenhagen.
|